Cultural bias occurs when a person starts making assumptions and judgments of another person through the lens of their own culture. Generally, two types of biases exist: implicit and explicit. Implicit bias refers to the attitudes or stereotypes people may hold unconsciously. Explicit bias represents conscious beliefs and practices that favor certain groups over others. While one seems more obvious to spot then the other, both are ultimately present in most of our realities, and they often shape our lives from generation to generation. Cultural bias is a phenomenon which grows as the world becomes more diverse, and one of the ways to help resolve it is by influencing the education system to work against it.
The education system plays a significant role in shaping how people are integrated into society. From an early age, children interact with teachers, peers, and institutions, forming the foundation for their future interactions and worldview. Without proper training, the cycle of cultural bias is likely to be reinforced in future generations. If educators are not trained to recognize and address biases, both in themselves and in their students, then these prejudices will only continue to perpetuate marginalization across generations, affecting workplaces, families, and society at large.
However, education also offers a unique opportunity to disrupt this cycle. By focusing on educational institutions, and prioritizing training teachers to navigate diverse classrooms, we can create a system which targets cultural bias, giving students a better chance of growing up with a sense of belonging and acceptance of one another and what makes them different. This new mentality could go from something in the classroom, to something they talk about and notice in their own homes with their parents, influencing people in a chain reaction towards a more respectfully diverse future.
The Impact of Implicit Bias on Educators
The impact of educator implicit bias can be catastrophic to a students experience. Implicit biases are pervasive; they present themselves in our subconscious and happen to all of us. They drive our behaviors towards one another and feed into our preconceived notions of each other. Educators are not exempt from this, nor are they specially trained to identify and steer away from these thoughts before they lead them to unfavorable behaviors.
Implicit biases could be about a person's age, gender, race, religion, sexual orientation, ability status and even physical appearance, like skin color, or extra weight. Sometimes, even though people know better about these things, they still have certain stereotypes stuck in their minds that influence how they behave and treat others. Erroneous thoughts and beliefs like these can be dealt with and re-directed individually, as long as people have the right knowledge to identify when it's happening and how to avoid it from being reflected in their actions.
Studies highlight that teachers sometimes hold stereotypes associated with identity and background, influencing their expectations of their students. For example, a study in 2016 revealed that teachers were less likely to recommend Black students for gifted programs, even when their academic performance was comparable to their white peers. Holding on to stereotypical beliefs about students based on the way that they look is not only unfair, but it can also lead to lower academic expectations, and reduced engagement.
Moreover, implicit biases can lead educators to favor students who share characteristics they view as traditionally "desirable." For example, in a class of 30 students, a teacher might unintentionally spend more time with those who resemble their own culture, past experiences or who align with their biases, leaving other students without the necessary support and attention. Due to the malleable nature of implicit biases, stakeholders in education must place a focus on training professional educators to catch themselves, re-direct and navigate diverse classroom environments that where this normally occurs.
Explicit Bias in Educational Policies and Practices
While implicit bias often operates subconsciously, explicit bias involves intentional actions or policies that favor certain groups. Explicit bias is evident in educational policies and practices that advantage specific groups intentionally. A strong example is seen in school disciplinary measures. According to the U.S. Department of Education, Black students are more than three times as likely to be suspended than their white counterparts, revealing a significant gap often rooted in biased policies. Disproportionate disciplinary actions in education can shape the way marginalized students will see their future. Rather than projecting a future where people will discipline them based off of their appearance, institutions could identify and eliminate explicit sources of bias, giving their students a fair shot at their future.
Explicit bias is also evident when more direct acts of discrimination occur, such as hate speech in class, or obvious preference of one student over another. An example in a classroom setting is when teachers choose male students to speak in class over female students. This can discourage female learners and can further enhance stereotypes against women in society. Curriculum choices also reflect explicit bias. When educational materials focus mainly on dominant cultural narratives, students from underrepresented backgrounds can feel alienated. For instance, a history curriculum that overlooks the achievements of diverse cultures can contribute to disengagement among students whose histories are not included. This disconnect can significantly affect their motivation to excel academically.
Observable Effects on Students
Cultural bias in education affects educators and students alike, creating an uncomfortable environment for everyone involved - especially the student. Research indicates that students who perceive bias may experience lower self-esteem and motivation in their studies. A study found that students who experience stereotype threat (where the fear of conforming to negative stereotypes influences performance) can score, on average, 20% lower in math and reading assessments compared to their peers. When this happens, children's true academic capabilities are not reflected accurately, and the image of marginalized communities being less educationally inclined is highlighted as a result. Children end up performing badly out of fear of being marginalized, rather than failing because of their lack of understanding of something.
Additionally, students who feel discriminated may develop a distrust of the educational system. This distrust can lead to reluctance in participating in classroom discussions and reluctance in caring about their educational outcome and future, which further widens the educational gulf. Schools that do not address cultural biases risk losing valuable contributions from diverse student voices.
Education is such a huge part of a person's social development. Children who develop distrust of the educational system also develop distrust in themselves and society. Their lack of self esteem will bleed into other areas in their life, affecting their choices and forcing them to see in a marginalized mindset, rather than a culturally aware one. The risk of losing valuable contributions from diverse voices could extend past education and straight into society.
Addressing Bias Through Training and Awareness
To tackle cultural bias, educators must first cultivate awareness and take proactive steps. Professional development programs focused on recognizing and addressing bias can be invaluable. These programs enable teachers to confront their biases and develop strategies for more inclusive classrooms.
Methods to Identify Bias in Educational Settings
Reflection and Self-Assessment: Encourage educators to regularly evaluate their teaching practices and ensure equitable treatment among all students. This can include personal journaling or peer discussions.
Feedback from Students and Parents: Maintain open communication with both students and parents to gather insights regarding perceptions of bias in the classroom environment.
Review of Educational Materials: Regularly assess curricula to highlight any biases, ensuring a broad representation of diverse cultural narratives.
Equity Audits: Schools should conduct equity audits to evaluate their practices and policies, striving for fairness and inclusiveness.
Implementing Inclusive Practices
Taking action to fulfil a diverse educational environment goes beyond merely recognizing biases. Here are effective strategies educators can implement:
Diversifying Curriculum: Teachers should incorporate a variety of cultural perspectives into the curriculum, ensuring all students see themselves represented. For example, integrating literature from authors of diverse backgrounds can create a more engaging classroom experience.
Culturally Responsive Teaching: This teaching style acknowledges and incorporates students' cultural references in learning, fostering a richer educational experience.
Setting High Expectations for All Students: Educators should maintain consistently high academic expectations, encouraging all students to believe in their potential to succeed.
Encouraging Critical Thinking: By inviting students to analyze and challenge existing biases within historical events or current issues, teachers can help develop a more thoughtful student body.
System-Wide Changes
While individual efforts are vital, systemic changes within educational institutions are equally necessary. Schools must critically review their policies and practices to ensure they promote equity. Key areas for improvement include:
Inclusive Hiring Practices: Implementing hiring strategies that diversify the teaching staff can help create environments that reflect student populations.
Policy Revisions: Review disciplinary policies regularly to limit both implicit and explicit biases, fostering a more equitable atmosphere for all students.
Community Engagement: Partnering with local organizations can provide schools with additional resources, support, and deeper cultural understanding.
Investing in a Fair Educational Future
Cultural bias in education creates barriers not only for educators and students but also for the entire education system. By exploring the consequences of implicit and explicit biases, educators can reevaluate their methodologies and policies to foster a more inclusive environment. They can also learn to hold their thoughts and actions accountable while familiarizing themselves with students and their diverse cultures.
Engaging with diverse perspectives and implementing equitable practices is essential for breaking the cycle of bias. By making a commitment to self-reflection, inclusivity, and systemic change, we can shape an educational landscape that appreciates and celebrates diversity, benefiting everyone in the process.
Instagram: @linguatico
LinkedIn: LinguatiCo
Comments